Only Murders in the Building Season 3 Revives a Fan-Favorite Character

Warning: This article contains SPOILERS for Only Murders in the Building season three.

The intrigue deepens and old characters resurface as we wade deeper into the third season of the popular show Only Murders in the Building. While our core protagonists – Charles, Oliver, and Mabel – continue their sleuthing in the grand old building they inhabit, a sense of transformation lurks in the show’s atmosphere. Their dedicated Podcasting, which was an instrumental motif in the previous seasons, has taken something of a backseat. If anything has the power to rejuvenate this part of the narrative, it’s the comeback of a voice that fans of the series know well.

If you’ve been keeping pace with the show, then brace yourselves because, spoiler alert, an old acquaintance has rejoined the plot. Remember Cinda Canning, brilliantly brought to life by Tina Fey? After the debacle in season two, where she was wrongfully accused of murder, many believed her chapter in the series was over. Oh, how mistaken we were.

The recently aired episode revealed Cinda, in all her irreverent glory, trying her hand at Podcasting once more. The twist? She’s attempting to regain the faith of her listeners following a rather scandalous hiatus. The brash and comically astute podcaster aims to clear the murky waters surrounding her, weaving her narrative of redemption.

In a candid conversation with TVLine, the showrunner, John Hoffman, shared some insights. “One of the smaller themes of the season is ‘What is legitimacy?’ and [Cinda’s return] fit well into that theme,” Hoffman reflected.

RELATED: Only Murders in the Building Showrunner Addresses Season 3 Premiere’s Shocking Double Twist

Shifting Allegiances: Mabel at the Crossroads of Trust & Opportunity

As the episode unfolds, it becomes clear that Cinda’s ambitions aren’t solely tethered to redemption. As viewers, we’re made privy to an ulterior motive: Cinda is gearing up to re-enter the world of criminal investigations, and she wants Mabel by her side. For Mabel, the stakes have changed this season. With financial constraints breathing down her neck and the impending reality of relocating from her aunt’s place, the proposal from Cinda – involving a generous sum to collaborate on the enigmatic Ben Glenroy case – seems enticing.

Hoffman offers an insightful peek into Mabel’s psyche at this juncture. Hoffman explained:

The suspense is tangible. With Cinda’s reentry, the narrative has certainly taken a twist. What remains to be seen is how the dynamics change, especially with the tempting prospect hanging over Mabel’s head. Will she be swayed by Cinda’s proposal? Or will her allegiance to her trusted comrades, Charles and Oliver, prevail?

This season promises a rollercoaster of emotions, alliances, and revelations. And as we have learned from Only Murders in the Building, expect the unexpected. The game is afoot!